Image copyright
Warren family collection
Hubert Warren (left) died in one of Australia’s first major plane accidents
On Friday 19 October, 1934, the passenger plane Miss Hobart fell from the sky to the sea.
Eight men, three woman and a baby boy fell with her, swallowed – it’s believed – by the waters of the Bass Strait that lies between Tasmania and mainland Australia.
The plane’s wreckage was never found.
One of those on board was a 33-year-old Anglican missionary, Rev Hubert Warren, who had been travelling to his new parish in Enfield, Sydney. His wife Ellie and four children had stayed behind, intending to follow by boat.
The reverend’s last present to his eight-year-old son, David, had been a crystal radio set that the boy treasured deeply.
As a boarder at Launceston Boys’ Grammar School in Tasmania, David Warren tinkered with the machine after lessons, learning what made it work. He charged friends a penny to listen to cricket matches, and within a few years was selling home-made copies at five shillings each.
Image copyright
Warren family collection
As a schoolboy, David was fascinated by electronics and learned to build his own radio sets
Young David was charismatic and a wonderful orator – a boy with star quality. His family, who were deeply religious, dreamed he would become an evangelical preacher.
But that was not to be. The gift from Rev Hubert, Man of God, had launched a love affair with Science.
It would prove to be of life-saving significance.
By his mid-twenties, David Warren had studied his way to a science degree from the University of Sydney, a diploma in education from Melbourne University and a PhD in chemistry from Imperial College, London.
His specialty was rocket science, and he went to work as a researcher for the Aeronautical Research Laboratories (ARL), a part of Australia’s Defence Department that focused on planes.
In 1953, the department loaned him to an expert panel trying to solve a costly and distressing mystery: why did the British de Havilland Comet, the world’s first commercial jet airliner and the great hope of the new Jet Age, keep crashing?
He thought it might be the fuel tanks; but there were dozens of possible causes and nothing but death and debris as evidence. The panel sat down to discuss what they knew.
“People were rattling on about staff training and pilots’ errors, and did a fin break off the tail, and all sorts of things that I knew nothing about,” Dr Warren recalled more than 50 years later.
“I found myself dreaming of something I’d seen the week before at Sydney’s first post-war trade fair. And that is – what claimed to be the first pocket recorder, the Miniphon. A German device. There’d been nothing before like it…”
The Miniphon was marketed as a dictation machine for businessmen, who could sit at their desks (or on trains and planes) recording letters that would later be typed up by their secretaries. David, who loved swing music and played the clarinet, only wanted one so he could make bootleg recordings of the jazz musician Woody Herman.
However, when one of his fellow scientists suggested the latest doomed Comet might have been hijacked, something clicked for him.
The chances that a recorder had been on board – and survived the fiery wreck – were basically nil. But what if every plane in the sky had a mini recorder in the cockpit? If it was tough enough, accident investigators would never be this confused again, because they’d have audio right up to the moment of the crash. At the very least, they’d know what the pilots had said and heard.
The idea fascinated him. Back at ARL, he rushed to tell his boss about it.
Alas, his superior didn’t share his enthusiasm. Dr Warren said he was told: “It’s nothing to do with chemistry or fuels. You’re a chemist. Give that to the instruments group and get on with blowing up fuel tanks.”
‘Talk about it and I’ll have to sack you’
David knew his idea for a cockpit recorder was a good one. Without official support, there was little he could do about it – but he couldn’t get it out of his mind.
When his boss was promoted, David pitched his invention again. His new superior was intrigued, and so was Dr Laurie Coombes, ARL’s chief superintendent. They urged him to keep working on it – but discreetly. Since it wasn’t a government-approved venture or a war-winning weapon, it couldn’t be seen to take up lab time or money.
Dr Warren said the chief superintendent had cautioned him: “If I find you talking to anyone, including me, about this matter, I will have to sack you.”
It was a sobering thought for a young man with a wife and two children.
But his boss’s backing extended to sneakily buying one of the precious new dictation recorders, and chalking it up as “an instrument required for the laboratory…”
Image copyright
Defence Science and Technology, Australia
David holding forth at ARL in 1958
Encouraged, Dr Warren wrote up his idea in a report, titled “A Device for Assisting Investigation into Aircraft Accidents”, and sent it out across the industry.
The pilots’ union responded with fury, branding the recorder a snooping device, and insisted “no plane would take off in Australia with Big Brother listening”.
That was one of his better reviews.
Australia’s civilian aviation authorities declared it had “no immediate significance”, and the air force feared it would “yield more expletives than explanations”.
Dr Warren was tempted to pack it all in.
But his eldest son, Peter, says his father was stubborn, with a non-conformist streak that coloured his whole worldview.
“He took us skiing,” he recalls, “but he did the skiing in washing-up gloves, because he wasn’t going to pay $30 for a pair of ski gloves. He wasn’t the least bit afraid. He wasn’t going to wait and follow the herd at all.”
It was in that spirit that Dr Warren took to his garage and assembled his 20-year-old radio parts. He’d decided the only way to overcome his critics’ mockery and suspicion was to build a solid prototype.
It would be the first ever “black box” flight recorder.
‘Put that lad on the next courier!’
One day in 1958, when the little flight recorder had been finished and finessed, the lab received an unusual visitor. Dr Coombes, the chief superintendent, was showing round a friend from England.
“Dave!” he said, “Tell him what you’re doing!”
Dr Warren explained: his world-first prototype used steel wire to store four hours of pilot voices plus instrument readings and automatically erased older records so it was reusable.
There was a pause, then the visitor said: “I say Coombes old chap, that’s a damn good idea. Put that lad on the next courier, and we’ll show it in London.”
The courier was a Hastings bomber aircraft, making a run to England. You had to know somebody pretty powerful to get a seat on it. Dr Warren wondered who this man was who was giving away tickets round the world to somebody he’d never met.
The answer was Robert Hardingham (later Sir Robert), the secretary of the British Air Registration Board and a former Air Vice-Marshall in the RAF.
In David’s words: “He was a hero. And he was a friend of Coombes, and if he gave away a seat, you took it.”
A few weeks later, Dr Warren was on a plane bound for England – with strict instructions not to tell Australia’s Department of Defence what he was really doing there, because “somebody would frown on it”.
In a near-unbelievable irony, the plane lost an engine over the Mediterranean.
Dr Warren recalled: “I said, ‘Chaps, we seem to have lost a donk – does anyone want to go back?’ But we’d come from Tunisia and it was about 45 degrees overnight. We didn’t want to go back to that hellhole.”
They decided they could make it if they ploughed on.
He recorded the rest of the flight, thinking that even if he died in that limping, one-engined bomber, “at least I’d have proved the bastards wrong!”
“But unfortunately we didn’t prang – we just landed safely…”
Image copyright
Warren family collection
By 1958, David and his wife Ruth had four children. The eldest, Peter, remembers him flying off to England
In England, Dr Warren presented “the ARL Flight Memory Unit” to the Royal Aeronautical Establishment and some commercial instrument-makers.
The Brits loved it. The BBC ran TV and radio programmes examining it, and the British civil aviation authority started work to make the device mandatory in civil aircraft. A Middlesex firm, S Davall and Sons, approached ARL about the production rights, and kicked off manufacturing.
Though the device started to be called “the black box”, the first ones off the line were orange so they’d be easier to find after a crash – and they remain so today.
Peter Warren believes the name dates from a 1958 interview his father gave the BBC.
“Right at the end there was a journalist who referred to this as a ‘black box’. It’s a generic word from electronics engineering, and the name stuck.”
Media playback is unsupported on your device
Image copyright
AFP/GettyImages
The so-called “black box” is in fact a strident orange colour
In 1960, Australia became the first country to make cockpit voice recorders mandatory, after an unexplained plane crash in Queensland killed 29 people. The ruling came from a judicial inquiry, and took a further three years to become law.
Today, black boxes are fire-proof, ocean-proof and encased in steel. And they are compulsory on every commercial flight.
It’s impossible to say how many people owe their lives to data captured in the death throes of a failing plane – to the flaws exposed, and the safety innovations that followed.
‘I’m a lucky bastard’
David Warren worked at ARL until his retirement in 1983, becoming its principal research scientist. He died on 19 July, 2010, at the age of 85.
Image copyright
Fairfax Media via Getty Images
David Warren pictured in 2002 with the first combined voice and data recorder
For more than 50 years, his pioneering work on the black box went almost unacknowledged. Finally in 1999, he was awarded the Australian Institute of Energy Medal, and then in 2002 was made an Officer of the Order of Australia (AO) for his service to the aviation industry.
Asked why it took so long for him to be recognised, his daughter Jenny observes: “His battle was inertia. He had this huge enquiring mind, scientifically visionary, and could see how it would work – how it would play out.
“He was sitting there in 1958, saying ‘this device can make this happen.'”
Peter Warren blames “a 1950s colonial mindset which said nothing good could come out of this country, and everything good would get invented in either the UK, or Germany or America”.
The historic secrecy surrounding ARL’s work, which is now more widely understood, is another likely factor.
Dr Warren lived to see Qantas name an Airbus A380 after him in 2008. Jenny Warren says she’s been trying to get a seat on it ever since.
But he never saw a penny in royalties from the black box.
Image copyright
Reuters
David Warren’s funeral featured a tongue-in-cheek nod to his legacy
He was often asked if he felt hard done by. Peter says his standard response was: “Yes, the government got the results of what I did. But then, they also didn’t charge me for the other hundred ideas that didn’t work.”
David’s children inherited his sense of humour.
At Peter’s urging, Dr Warren’s death notice included his personal catchphrase: “I’m a lucky bastard.”
At Jenny’s request, he was buried in a casket labelled: “Flight Recorder Inventor: Do Not Open.”
Do they think of their dad when flying?
His daughter replies simply: “Every time.”
Image copyright
Fairfax Media via Getty Images
